The CBF admitted that the refereeing team for the match between Corinthians and Grêmio, this Monday (18), made a mistake by not awarding a penalty in favor of the Gaucho team in stoppage time. However, this does not make it legal for the CBF to cancel the match. Related Corinthians Striker Corinthians Striker holds youth records in South America Corinthians 20/09/2023 Futebol Nacional Gaciba condemns VAR's action in Corinthians x Grêmio, but criticizes CBF's "public penalty" Futebol Nacional VAR Futebol Nacional 19/09/ 2020. removed by CBF; referee is under analysis Football Nacional 19/09/2023 According to article 259 of the Brazilian Code of Sports Law (CBJD), the cancellation of a duel is only permitted if the rules are not applied, which is outside the context of the game. the situation at Neo Química Arena, where the error resulted from an incomplete interpretation of the instructions. + Update your stock of Timão shirts with the LANCEFUT coupon 10% OFF What happened at the Corinthians stadium opens up a debate about errors of fact and law. In the episode in question, the failure of the arbitration was in fact - It is possible to understand that this view makes it even clearer that the issue is a mere factual error resulting from the arbitrator's misinterpretation of the arbitration award. the behavior practiced by the athlete on the playing field, not due to lack of knowledge of the rules of the match referee and/or the VAR referee - explains Felipe Crisafulli, lawyer specializing in sports law at Ambiel Advogados. Even though the CBF did not take Corinthians and Grêmio's error into account, the match team's VAR was removed. In addition to Emerson de Almeida Ferreira, from Minas Gerais, responsible for video arbitration, assistants Johnny Barros de Oliveira (SC) and Michel Patrick Costa Guimarães (MG) were also sent to the recycling program. Field referee Wilton Pereira Sampaio will have the situation analyzed and may also receive a penalty. For Péricles Bassols, the video referee should recommend that Wilton check the movement using a monitor at the side of the field. In the audio of the conversation between the on-field referee and the VAR team, it is recorded that Emerson feels that striker Yuri Alberto is pulling his arm back and that is why the block is not made. + LANCEFUT coupon with 10% discount for sports fanatics on purchases over R$ 299.90 Emerson de Almeida Ferreira, from Minas Gerais, was sent off after a refereeing error at Corinthians and Grêmio (Photo: Marcos Cunha/Fatopress/Gazeta Press ) - The player, although he is in that position, I think he is natural for this ball game, defensively, he will not block. For me he won't block, he'll get the ball. This is different from blocking. He withdraws his hand. He doesn't move his hand towards the ball. He collects. Wilton, offer verified, ok. You can play, the player pulls his hand back, is in a competitive position and the ball goes towards his hand - said the video referee when reviewing the move. Emerson de Almeida Ferreira's speech confirms that the referee team's error was one of interpretation, and not ignorance of the rule, which leaves no room for stopping the match. If Grêmio wants to try to stop the game, which is unlikely, they will have to gather evidence that proves that the penalty was not awarded due to ignorance of the rule, or even intent, which would fall under article 243-A of the CBJD. which provides for “acting in a manner contrary to sporting ethics with the aim of influencing the outcome of a game, competition or equivalent”. + See Brasileirão-2023 table and classification by clicking here - Furthermore, the possible allegation that the video referee did not invite the field referee to analyze the monitor images should not change the situation, as the STJD understands that possible errors in the procedure of VAR does not constitute a legal error and does not give the right to cancel the match, as the VAR protocol is a procedural rule in the form of a “booklet of instructions”, highlights Felipe. Crisafulli's match between Corinthians and Grêmio was in the 15th round of the Brazilian Championship, with Timão fighting to escape the relegation zone, behind 17th-placed Santos, while Grêmio is in the table. top of the table, 11 points behind leader Botafogo. Jr with Mbappé at Real Madrid draws attention online 2 On the field Brasileirão: See title chances after Botafogo's draw, Palmeiras wins 3 Off the field Botafogo fans blame the partial defeat: 'It's necessary to fail' 4 Throw! Biz How much did Rayssa Leal earn for winning the SLS stage in Tokyo? 5 Flamengo Flamengo's stadium has a capacity for 78 thousand people and is inspired by the European ones; Check out the photos from Lance's newsletter! Stay up to date on sports and your favorite team with just 1 minute of reading! Sign up for the best sports of your morning! Article More news Stay up to date! See more Brasileirão Corinthians is a decisive week for Hugo Souza's stay 25.11.2024 - 07:30 Brasileirão Fluminense x Criciúma: artificial intelligence predicts the result of the game 25.11.2024 - 06:10 Brasileirão is the best place for Flamen. Brazil's last three 11/25/2024 - 06:00 Brasileirão Corinthians: Garro is the Brasileirão's top scorer; see the list 11/25/2024 - 05:15 Brasileirão Palmeiras has coincidences to reach the final against Botafogo 11/25/2024 - 05:00 Brasileirão Corinthians rewrites its history in the Brasileirão WC after 11 years of elimination /25/2024 - 04:30 Brasileirão Corinthians achieves the sixth consecutive victory and interrupts the Brasileirão 11/24/2024 - 9:19 pm Brasileirão Sport Série A: Fans go crazy with Lucas Lima's golden night 11/24/2024 - 8:58 pm Related Corinthians Striker Corinthians striker holds records among young American players.0 Corinthians /2023 National Football Gaciba condemns VAR’s performance in Corinthians x Grêmio, but criticizes “punishment public” by CBF Futebol Nacional 19/09/2023 Futebol Nacional Corinthians VAR x Grêmio removed by CBF; the referee is under analysis Football Nacional 19.09.2023Find out if the game between Corinthians and Grêmio can be canceled after the CBF admits an arbitration error
The CBF admitted that the refereeing team for the match between Corinthians and Grêmio, this Monday (18), made a mistake by not awarding a penalty in favor of the Gaucho team in stoppage time. However, this does not make it legal for the CBF to cancel the match. Related Corinthians Striker Corinthians Striker holds youth records in South America Corinthians 20/09/2023 Futebol Nacional Gaciba condemns VAR's action in Corinthians x Grêmio, but criticizes CBF's "public penalty" Futebol Nacional VAR Futebol Nacional 19/09/ 2020. removed by CBF; referee is under analysis Football Nacional 19/09/2023 According to article 259 of the Brazilian Code of Sports Law (CBJD), the cancellation of a duel is only permitted if the rules are not applied, which is outside the context of the game. the situation at Neo Química Arena, where the error resulted from an incomplete interpretation of the instructions. + Update your stock of Timão shirts with the LANCEFUT coupon 10% OFF What happened at the Corinthians stadium opens up a debate about errors of fact and law. In the episode in question, the failure of the arbitration was in fact - It is possible to understand that this view makes it even clearer that the issue is a mere factual error resulting from the arbitrator's misinterpretation of the arbitration award. the behavior practiced by the athlete on the playing field, not due to lack of knowledge of the rules of the match referee and/or the VAR referee - explains Felipe Crisafulli, lawyer specializing in sports law at Ambiel Advogados. Even though the CBF did not take Corinthians and Grêmio's error into account, the match team's VAR was removed. In addition to Emerson de Almeida Ferreira, from Minas Gerais, responsible for video arbitration, assistants Johnny Barros de Oliveira (SC) and Michel Patrick Costa Guimarães (MG) were also sent to the recycling program. Field referee Wilton Pereira Sampaio will have the situation analyzed and may also receive a penalty. For Péricles Bassols, the video referee should recommend that Wilton check the movement using a monitor at the side of the field. In the audio of the conversation between the on-field referee and the VAR team, it is recorded that Emerson feels that striker Yuri Alberto is pulling his arm back and that is why the block is not made. + LANCEFUT coupon with 10% discount for sports fanatics on purchases over R$ 299.90 Emerson de Almeida Ferreira, from Minas Gerais, was sent off after a refereeing error at Corinthians and Grêmio (Photo: Marcos Cunha/Fatopress/Gazeta Press ) - The player, although he is in that position, I think he is natural for this ball game, defensively, he will not block. For me he won't block, he'll get the ball. This is different from blocking. He withdraws his hand. He doesn't move his hand towards the ball. He collects. Wilton, offer verified, ok. You can play, the player pulls his hand back, is in a competitive position and the ball goes towards his hand - said the video referee when reviewing the move. Emerson de Almeida Ferreira's speech confirms that the referee team's error was one of interpretation, and not ignorance of the rule, which leaves no room for stopping the match. If Grêmio wants to try to stop the game, which is unlikely, they will have to gather evidence that proves that the penalty was not awarded due to ignorance of the rule, or even intent, which would fall under article 243-A of the CBJD. which provides for “acting in a manner contrary to sporting ethics with the aim of influencing the outcome of a game, competition or equivalent”. + See Brasileirão-2023 table and classification by clicking here - Furthermore, the possible allegation that the video referee did not invite the field referee to analyze the monitor images should not change the situation, as the STJD understands that possible errors in the procedure of VAR does not constitute a legal error and does not give the right to cancel the match, as the VAR protocol is a procedural rule in the form of a “booklet of instructions”, highlights Felipe. Crisafulli's match between Corinthians and Grêmio was in the 15th round of the Brazilian Championship, with Timão fighting to escape the relegation zone, behind 17th-placed Santos, while Grêmio is in the table. top of the table, 11 points behind leader Botafogo. Jr with Mbappé at Real Madrid draws attention online 2 On the field Brasileirão: See title chances after Botafogo's draw, Palmeiras wins 3 Off the field Botafogo fans blame the partial defeat: 'It's necessary to fail' 4 Throw! Biz How much did Rayssa Leal earn for winning the SLS stage in Tokyo? 5 Flamengo Flamengo's stadium has a capacity for 78 thousand people and is inspired by the European ones; Check out the photos from Lance's newsletter! Stay up to date on sports and your favorite team with just 1 minute of reading! Sign up for the best sports of your morning! Article More news Stay up to date! See more Brasileirão Corinthians is a decisive week for Hugo Souza's stay 25.11.2024 - 07:30 Brasileirão Fluminense x Criciúma: artificial intelligence predicts the result of the game 25.11.2024 - 06:10 Brasileirão is the best place for Flamen. Brazil's last three 11/25/2024 - 06:00 Brasileirão Corinthians: Garro is the Brasileirão's top scorer; see the list 11/25/2024 - 05:15 Brasileirão Palmeiras has coincidences to reach the final against Botafogo 11/25/2024 - 05:00 Brasileirão Corinthians rewrites its history in the Brasileirão WC after 11 years of elimination /25/2024 - 04:30 Brasileirão Corinthians achieves the sixth consecutive victory and interrupts the Brasileirão 11/24/2024 - 9:19 pm Brasileirão Sport Série A: Fans go crazy with Lucas Lima's golden night 11/24/2024 - 8:58 pm Related Corinthians Striker Corinthians striker holds records among young American players.0 Corinthians /2023 National Football Gaciba condemns VAR’s performance in Corinthians x Grêmio, but criticizes “punishment public” by CBF Futebol Nacional 19/09/2023 Futebol Nacional Corinthians VAR x Grêmio removed by CBF; the referee is under analysis Football Nacional 19.09.2023